Does Kay Jewelers Sell Real Diamonds? - Savvy

Gift Cards Travel Does Kay Jewelers Sell Real Diamonds?



ยท 6 min read

There is a lot of mystery and misunderstanding regarding diamonds. Many buyers aren't sure what distinguishes a real diamond from a fake one or whether they can trust the caliber of diamonds offered by well-known retailers like Kay Jewelers.

This blog post will look into the topic, "Does Kay Jewelers sell genuine diamonds?" and give you all the info you need to make an educated decision. Read on!


Who owns Kay Jewelers?

Edmund and Soul Kaufman established Kay Jewelers in 1916. The two got their start in Pennsylvania with a modest shop establishment run by their father. With the slogan "every kiss begins with Kay" the company experienced a breakthrough in sales in 1997. Within months, sales of the product doubled.

The business expanded quickly and gained a reputation for producing diamond engagement rings of the highest caliber. With locations in every significant mall, Kay Jewelers is currently one of the biggest jewelers in the country.


Does Kay Jewelers sell real diamonds?

There are many people who are asking this question. In recent years, controversies have surfaced over the authenticity of the diamonds sold by Kay Jewelers. Let's look at the information that is available regarding the veracity of these stones.

First of all, keep in mind that not all of the diamonds sold by Kay Jewelers are imitations. The shop offers a wide variety of real diamonds that are flawless and well-cut. A few isolated occurrences with lab-grown diamonds are what started the discussion.

Do Kay diamonds actually exist? And the most of them are. It's important to be conscious of the chance that certain stones could be fakes, though. It's advisable to buy from a reputed jeweler if you're looking for a real diamond rather than taking a chance at an unreliable source, like a flea market.


How can you tell if a diamond is real?

What distinguishes genuine diamonds from fake diamonds is a common question. We've detailed some key differences between real and fake diamonds below.


Fake diamonds are constructed of glass or other materials, whereas real diamonds are formed from carbon. They might resemble real diamonds extremely closely, but they will never be able to match their unique qualities.

Where they are cultivated

The earth is where true diamonds are mined. They are extracted from kimberlite and volcanic pipelines in various parts of the world. Fake diamonds, on the other hand, can be created by anybody with access to a lab.

Moh Scale

The Moh's hardness of genuine diamonds is around ten. This makes it one of the hardest substances on the planet, second only to actual diamonds.

Diamond substitutes are not as hard. They might even scratch if you expose them to something else, such a diamond file or piece of emery paper.


While phony diamonds only emit light from their tips, real diamonds emit light from their full surface. This is due to the fact that real diamonds have thousands of facets, whereas imitation diamonds only have a handful.


A diamond's cost is determined by its quality characteristics, including composition, color, clarity, and cut. Real diamonds typically cost more than imitation diamonds.


Will a jewelry store tell me if my diamond is real?

It might be difficult to tell the difference between genuine and imitation diamonds. As a result, a lot of people have been duped by scammers. Regardless of how stunning they may appear, one must exercise caution when purchasing diamonds. The following advice can help you distinguish between fake and real diamonds.

Request a diamond certification

Diamonds are valuable gemstones. It is imperative that they obtain the quality certification due to the high price tag that comes with them. This certificate verifies the stone's authenticity and informs you of the stone's value in terms of clarity, cut, carat, and color.

In addition, a Diamond Certificate is an independent lab report from the GIA (Gemological Institute of America) or AGS rating diamonds (American Gem Society).

Conduct a water test.

You can use this test to determine whether the diamond is real or fake. Check where the diamond lands after submerging it in water. A false diamond will always float to the surface of the water, whereas a real diamond would always sink to the bottom.

Look for inclusions

Any inclusions in a diamond are invisible to the naked eyes. Because of this, it requires a specialist with specialized skills and equipment to discover these faults.

Look inside the stone for tiny, black specks that might be crystals using your hand or a magnifying glass. If they are, the diamond is real; if not, you have been duped and have been sold a fake.

Fog or breath test

You can use this test to determine whether the diamond is real or fake. Simply inhale on it, and if the fog disappears soon, you may be sure it's false because a genuine diamond will retain the moisture for a longer period of time.

Do a scratch test

One of the easiest tests to perform requires only a fingernail. Try using your nail to scratch the diamond's surface. A true diamond will exhibit some signs of wear and tear, however a fake diamond won't leave any scratches on its surface.


Are Kay Jewelers diamonds GIA certified?

No, they are not. This is a weakness of Kay Jewelers that should be pointed out to potential customers.

The Kay jewelers' diamonds are not GIA-certified. This can raise a red flag because it makes it difficult to judge the diamond's quality.

The clarity, carat, cut, and color of a diamond are all rated by the Gia Certification laboratory. It becomes difficult to be assured that you are purchasing the quality that has been provided to you without an internationally recognized certification.

Many Kay diamond buyers educate themselves on diamond grades or go with a diamond professional. This shouldn't be happening.

The fact that Kay does not disclose this information to its consumers should be made known to diamond shoppers. A certificate removes buyers' concerns regarding quality. At Kay, certain diamonds have an independent certificate, but not all of them.


What quality diamonds does Kay Jewelers use?

Both pre-set engagement rings and a "make your own" alternative are available from Kay.
We would immediately suggest using caution while selecting a pre-set ring. Since you'll be purchasing the diamond on a whim, you should anticipate that the core stone will be of poorer grade than ideal.

For their pre-set engagement rings, Kay Jewelers often uses diamonds with an I1 clarity grade. This is not a clarity grade that we would suggest to someone searching for a stunning diamond to complete their engagement ring.

Eye-clean I1 diamonds can be found, but they are harder to locate, and without the ability to see the diamond in the pre-set engagement rings, you run a significant danger of getting a visibly included stone for a hefty premium. This problem is not exclusive to Kay's. In our experience, huge chain merchants seldom prioritize high-quality diamonds in their pre-set jewelry (with the exception of genuine premium brands like Tiffany & Co.), thus I was never able to recommend them..


Final thoughts

The cut is the distinguishing characteristic when it comes to a stone's sparkle, but the clarity is just behind it. Since Kay Jewelers falls short on both of these, it is challenging for me to think of a circumstance in which I would suggest them to a customer.

They offer an excellent assortment of settings, and their website is gradually catching up to the standards we have come to expect from diamond e-commerce sites, but until their diamonds catch up, they will continue to receive a 2/5 rating.